China has nurtured the world's oldest continuous painting
tradition. Many of the artistic concepts that the West has developed
only in the past hundred years were already in the mainstream of China's
art world for centuries. Few westerners, however, can name a single
Chinese painter or painting. ABODE OF ILLUSION is a film which explores
the life and art of painter Chang Dai-chien, an artist who symbolizes
a bridge between China's past and present, as well as between East and
West. Chang was the first Chinese artist who achieved international
recognition both through his original paintings and through his skills
at emulating, and forging, past masters. His vision and courage to embrace
the past and to re-legitimize art traditions which had fallen out of
favor made him a landmark figure in Chinese painting.
Chang Dai-chien was born in 1899 to a merchant family
of modest means in the town of Neijiang, Sichuan province. The name
Dai-chien was not given to him by his family, but by a Buddhist abbot
during his brief attempt at Buddhist monkhood as a young adult. "Dai-chien"
comes from the notion of the boundless world of the Buddhist spirit,
described in scriptures as "three thousand times infinity."
The first impetus behind Chang's artistic development came from his
mother, a locally-known painter and embroidery designer. Later in his
youth, Chang settled in the cosmopolitan city of Shanghai, where he
studied under two famous calligraphers who were also known for their
poetry and paintings. This experience provided Chang with an important
base in the traditions and sensibilities of Chinese art.
Following the traditional belief that a learned person must "travel
ten thousand miles and read ten thousand books," Chang travelled
extensively throughout China, following in the footsteps of artists
of past ages. By the 1930's and 40's, he had established himself as
a preeminent figure in the art circles of Beijing and Shanghai.
In 1948, due to political upheavals, Chang left the Chinese mainland,
never to return. After living three decades in Brazil and the United
States, Chang settled in Taiwan in 1978. There, he built an elaborate
estate and garden for himself which he dubbed "The Abode of Illusion,"
derived, like his name, from Buddhist scripture. Chang died in 1983
at the age of eighty-four.
Chang Dai-chien embarked on his artistic career at a time when artists
in China were experiencing a crisis generated both from within the Chinese
tradition itself and from the challenge of the West. Many artists responded
by adopting, wholesale, Western techniques and sensibilities. Chang
Dai-chien, however, insisted on drawing inspiration for his paintings
from within the Chinese tradition, searching the entire past of Chinese
art in order to find his own voice.
The aspect of Chang Dai-chien's artistic career which generates the
most controversy is his role as a forger of old master paintings. Chang's
forgeries in themselves represent an impressive collection of art, spanning
a thousand years of Chinese tradition. ABODE OF ILLUSION provides different
perspectives on the issues of quality versus authenticity, and on how
the market influences our evaluations of art. For example, a rather
unconventional perspective is offered by art dealer Hugh Moss, who sees
the forger in Chang Dai-chien as a medium capable of contacting the
past and a spiritual reincarnation of the great masters of old. Moss
points out that the marketplace tends to guide our questions about art,
but, in the end, is only one aspect of the art. Moss suggests that if
we can divorce ourselves from the marketplace and deal simply with the
spiritual quality of the art, then many of Chang Dai-chien's paintings
are going to turn out to be the masterpieces of the future, whether
they bear an old master's name, or Chang's own.
ABODE OF ILLUSION presents Chang Dai-chien's life and art principally
from a Chinese perspective - through the reminiscences of people who
bore witness to his art as well as his character. Some of them are important
historical figures in their own right. Chang Hsueh-liang (Zhang Xueliang),
son of the northern warlord Zhang Zuolin, became known as "the
Young Marshall" after he took command of his father's army in Manchuria.
Zhang kidnapped Chiang Kai-shek in December 1936 (the Xian incident)
to force Chiang into joining an united front against the Japanese. During
the 1930's, Chang Hsueh-liang was a prominent collector of Chinese art.
Among his most valued old master works were forgeries by his good friend
Chang Dai-chien. Another friend, Long Chin-san (who was 100 years old
when he was interviewed for the film), is considered the father of Chinese
photography. Independent of western photographic practices, Long developed
a style of composite photography inspired by Chinese landscape painting,
and shared many of Chang Dai-chien's artistic sensibilities.
Others in the film were people whose lives were radically influenced
by Chang Dai-chien's art. As a young student, Duan Wenjie was so moved
by an exhibition of Chang's copies of the Dunhuang murals that he spent
the rest of his life researching and studying the art in the Caves of
a Thousand Buddhas in Dunhuang, where he now heads a major research
institute. Qiu Xiaoqiu saw Chang's paintings as a child and was so impressed
that Chang became a lifelong obsession - so much so that Qiu later wrote
a play in homage to Chang's career and memory. Arnold Chang (now a Vice
President at Sotheby's) was nine years old when he first saw Chang Dai-chien's
paintings in a New York exhibition. This had a profound impact on his
sense of identity as a Chinese American and triggered a lifetime pursuit
of Chinese art.
As with their past work, the filmmakers of ABODE OF ILLUSION approach
filmmaking as a process of discovery rather than that of simply finding
illustrations for a pre-written script. As they collect materials and
interview subjects for the film, a structure is revealed. In ABODE OF
ILLUSION, several locations provide the main structural fabric through
which the story of Chang Dai-chien's life and some issues of art history
are interwoven. For example, shots of the Yellow Mountains (Huangshan)
provide the context to discuss Chinese ideas about nature and art; cosmopolitan
Hong Kong serves as a backdrop to explore some aspects of the art marketplace
and Chang's stature within that arena.
The filmmaking process also influences the weight given to particular
episodes of Chang's life in the film. As they traced Chang's travels,
the filmmakers gained further appreciation for his dedication to the
pursuit of artistic inspiration. An overland trip along the ancient
silk road to Dunhuang, for example, still presents difficulties despite
modern transportation. Chang not only went there in 1941, but also
stayed for over two years under harsh conditions. Seeing the brilliant
paintings of Dunhuang at the end of such a journey further underscored
for the filmmakers the importance of the role Chang played in reintroducing
styles which had fallen into disfavor and in opening up new options
and possibilities for Chinese art.
ABODE OF ILLUSION does not intend to be a definitive
statement on Chang Dai-chien as an artist, but rather raises questions
and challenges assumptions about how we understand art, such as the
relationship between originality and tradition and between abstraction
and representation. Chang's life and work provide a vehicle by which
we can examine these issues from a fresh perspective.